“This dirt’s-eye-view of history provides an interesting perspective on a vast range of topics, from the vanquishing commons and the rise of private estates in Europe to the drive to colonize the Americas, from slavery and the Industrial Revolution to floods and famines in nineteenth- and early-twentieth-century China. And no book on dirt can pass lightly over the Depression-era Dust Bowl or its lesser-know Soviet counterpart.”
— Bookforum
“Sobering. . . . A timely text that will no doubt stimulate the discussion of this issue, and its potential solutions, for years to come.”
— Environment & History
"A compelling study on soil: why we need it, how we have used and abused it, how we can protect it, and what happens when we let it slip through our fingers."
— New Scientist
“Tell(s) a story which we cannot afford to ignore. . . . Well and eloquently told.”
— Financial Times
“Excellent, clearly written addition to the field. . . . Highly recommended.”
— CHOICE
“Anyone interested in environmental issues should read this book. . . . Entertains and stimulates thought.”
— Times Higher Education
“Makes fascinating bridges between geology, archeology, and history in studying the relationship between soils and civilizations.”
— Journal of Soil and Water Conservation
“Montgomery has produced a fine study that cycles through history, builds on a series of case studies, and makes comparisons across significant periods of time--all of which make this book an enjoyable read . . . Historians who study the rise and fall of civilizations must acknowledge the important questions raised by Montgomery’s ground-breaking work.”
— H-Net Reviews
“Dirt jumps across geologic time and space and argues that how societies fare in the long run depends on how they treat their soils. Simple. Concise. You are your dirt.”
— Hobby Farms
“Strengthen[s] appreciation for how important the soil is to our existence. . . . It is a must read for anyone who works with soil, and it should be of interest to all who care about our natural resources.”
— Great Plains Research
“A compelling read. . . . Enlightening, well founded and thoroughly researched.”
— Treehugger
“Timely. . . Strongly recommend[ed] for both the general public and the archeological community.”
— Journal of Field Archaeology
“Timely. . . Strongly recommend(ed) for both the general public and the archeological community.”
— Journal of Field Archaeology
“Sounds an ever timely and necessary clarion call for our generation at long last to stop exacerbating the abuses of the past and, wherever possible, to begin rectifying their dire consequences.”
— Vadose Zone Journal
“This book provides a useful and engaging primer on the history of humanity’s understanding of and relationship with soil.”
— Isis
“A comprehensive and readable summary of how civilizations have depended on the half-meter of life-generating topsoil that mantles our continents.”
— Geotimes
"From this gritty and compelling state-of-our-earth report comes the inescapable truth that we are nothing if not dirty-minded. A brilliant and essential book."—Roger Swain, science editor of Horticulture magazine
"The relationship between soils and societies has been crucial for humankind for 10,000 years. David Montgomery brings a geomorphologist's eye and a world-historical vision to the subject, showing why it demands our attention."—J.R. McNeill, author of Something New Under the Sun
“In our cyber-charged age, it’s easy to forget that all six billion of us stand on the thin skin of the earth. Humanity is agriculture and agriculture is soil, just as it has been for 10,000 years. David Montgomery—a competent digger of dirt and an engaging storyteller—shows how a close look at the soil can reveal a surprising amount about who we are and where we are headed.”—Richard Manning, author of Against the Grain: How Agriculture Has Hijacked Civilization