Cover Image

Larger ImageView Larger


Luxury and Rubble

Civility and Dispossession in the New Saigon

Erik Harms (Author)

Other Formats Available:
A free ebook version of this title is available through Luminos, University of California Press’s Open Access publishing program for monographs. Visit to learn more.

Luxury and Rubble is the tale of two cities in Ho Chi Minh City. It is the story of two planned, mixed-use residential and commercial developments that are changing the face of Vietnam’s largest city. Since the early 1990s, such developments have been steadily reorganizing urban landscapes across the country. For many Vietnamese, they are a symbol of the country’s emergence into global modernity and of post-socialist economic reforms. However, they are also sites of great contestation, sparking land disputes and controversies over how to compensate evicted residents. In this penetrating ethnography, Erik Harms vividly portrays the human costs of urban reorganization as he explores the complex and sometimes contradictory experiences of individuals grappling with the forces of privatization in a socialist country.
List of Illustrations

Introduction: Luxury and Rubble

Part I. Luxury
1. Civilizing the Wastelands: A Short History of Urban Development in Phú M? Hung
2. Civilization City
3. Exercising Consciousness: Self and Society in a Privatizing Space of Exclusion

Part II. Rubble
4. Th? Thiêm Futures Past: A Short History of Seeing without Seeing
5. Building a Civilized, Modern, and Sentimental City
6. From the Rubble

Conclusion: Civility and Dispossession
Erik Harms is Associate Professor of Anthropology and Southeast Asia Studies at Yale University and the author of Saigon’s Edge: On the Margins of Ho Chi Minh City.
"Erik Harms’s Luxury and Rubble is a work of fine-grained thick description that patiently walks readers through the rapid economic, cultural, and socio-spatial shifts that remade Ho Chi Minh City. . . superb, even-handed."—Cross-Currents
"With captivating ethnography and trenchant analysis, Erik Harms delves deeply into two communities created and destroyed by redevelopment in contemporary Ho Chi Minh City. He poignantly shows how master plans defining personhood in terms of property rights empower some to live in luxury, while leaving others in the rubble of dispossession.”—Ann Marie Leshkowich, author of Essential Trade: Vietnamese Women in Changing Marketplace
"Beautifully written. . . . A remarkable achievement in urban studies and a must-read for anyone interested in changing spatial form, sociality, rights consciousness, and class dynamics in neoliberal times.”—Li Zhang, author of In Search of Paradise: Middle-Class Living in a Chinese Metropolis
"Once in a while, a book comes along and makes us rethink how cities and capitalism work. Luxury and Rubble is one of those, giving us new conceptual insights into urbanism and doing so through an intensely lived and beautifully narrated ethnography.”—Ananya Roy, editor of Worlding Cities: Asian Experiments and the Art of Being Global

"An invaluable contribution to the ethnographic literature on ‘creative destruction,’ Harms’ rich comparative study of two planned urban developments in Ho Chi Minh City brings much needed attention to the sobering consequences of the reordering of post-imperial and late-socialist urban space in Vietnam by offering a deeply humanistic portrayal of those very urban actors whose social worlds hang in the balance between precarity and prosperity.”—Christina Schwenkel, author of The American War in Contemporary Vietnam: Transnational Remembrance and Representation

"In this meticulously researched investigation, Erik Harms brilliantly maps the new geographies of dispossession, property rights, political subjectivity and everyday life that are emerging in conjunction with urban redevelopment projects in post-liberalization Ho Chi Minh City."—Neil Brenner, author of Critique of Urbanization and New State Spaces  

Join UC Press

Members receive 20-40% discounts on book purchases. Find out more