From the opening sequence, in which mid-nineteenth-century Indian fishermen hear the possibility of redemption in an old woman's madness, No Aging in India captures the reader with its interplay of story and analysis. Drawing on more than a decade of ethnographic work, Lawrence Cohen links a detailed investigation of mind and body in old age in four neighborhoods of the Indian city of Varanasi (Banaras) with events and processes around India and around the world. This compelling exploration of senility—encompassing not only the aging body but also larger cultural anxieties—combines insights from medical anthropology, psychoanalysis, and postcolonial studies. Bridging literary genres as well as geographic spaces, Cohen responds to what he sees as the impoverishment of both North American and Indian gerontologies—the one mired in ambivalence toward demented old bodies, the other insistent on a dubious morality tale of modern families breaking up and abandoning their elderly. He shifts our attention irresistibly toward how old age comes to matter in the constitution of societies and their narratives of identity and history.
No Aging in India Alzheimer's, The Bad Family, and Other Modern Things
About the Book
Reviews
"This is a powerful, provocative book, rich with meaning. Lawrence Cohen weaves together challenging, revealing theory with vivid ethnographic images—of white-clad stooped women mingling with hungry dogs on the narrow lanes of Varanasi (Benaras); of a 'hot-minded' mother-in-law yelling out her window for someone to come save her, thus inculpating a 'Bad Family' and uncaring daughter-in- law; of an eager anthropologist trying to find senile old people with whom to do research. By the end the reader gains a new awareness of an important dimension of social and political life in India, as well as of what medical anthropology, gerontology, and ethnographic writing can be."—Anthropological Quarterly
"In studying 'what is not there' in India—aging as a disease—Cohen provides a richly documented view of what is there, especially of how people talk about things like Westernization and nuclear families as 'bad things.' No Aging in India packs in many details but also offers valuable comparative generalizations (with caution) that defy pure Geertzian guidelines about the sanctity of the local. . . . Monitoring the impacts of globalization and localization of Western views of aging, including gerontology, is another key area of future research prompted by this important book."—Pacific Affairs
"No Aging in India challenge[s] the ways in which we think about aging and senility, kinship and its undoing, medicine and the nation, language and the possibilities of ethnographic writing, and what it means to do the anthropology of South Asia. . . . [It] has helped to forge new openings and connections . . . in broader fields like anthropology, science and technology studies, South Asian Studies and critical gerontology."—Somatosphere
"No book in medical anthropology matches No Aging in India in its extraordinary richness of ethnographic detail. A feast of stories, lives, and theory--it contains such a thickness of social experience that the reader feels he or she has become a part of India's local worlds. Lawrence Cohen has written one of the finest ethnographic monographs I have read. A triumph of field research and writing, this book will, I feel sure, set the standard for the next wave of ethnographies in medical anthropology."—Arthur Kleinman, author of Writing at the Margin
Table of Contents
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS
THE GROUND OF THE ARGUMENT
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
NOTE ON TRANSCRIPTION, TRANSLATION, AND TRANSLITERATION
INTRODUCTION
The Mad Old Woman of the Millennium
The Age of Alzheimer's
The View from the River
Dulari
1. ORIENTATIONS
The ,Zagreb Tamasha
Whats Wrong with This Picture?
The Better Brain
Tropical Softening
Embodying Probate
A Medical Explanation
The Senile Body
An Anthropological Picaresque
Of Varanasi
World Wide Web
2. ALZHEIMER'S HELL
No Aging in America! Leading Scientists Reveal
Alzheimer's Subjectivity, and the the Old West
The Geriatric Paradox
Oublier Postmodern Aging
A Witch's Curse
The Senile Climacteric
Alzheimer's Family
Nuns and Doctors
3. KNOWLEDGE, PRACTICE, AND THE BAD FAMILY
On Gerontological Objects
The 'Aging in India" Series
Internationalist Science
The "Golden Isles"
Gerontology as Cultural Critique
BP Checks:The Volunteer Agency
Free Radical Exchange:The Geriatric Clinic
Into the Woods:The Retirement Ashram
Mothers versus Aunties: The Old Age Home
Aitasaa Pralapa
MEMORY BANKS
The Embodiment of Anxiety
The Promise of Rasayana
The Marketing of Memory
Memory and Capital
Forgetting as a Path to Truth
Meri Lata Mahan
THE ANGER OF THE RISHIS
Hot Brains
Sixtyishness and Seventy-twoness
Oedipus in India
Counting the Days and Hours
Old Women at the Polls
The Phenomenology of the Voice
The Familial Body
The Dying Space
Taking Voices Seriously
The Philosophers Mother
6. THE MALADJUSTMENT OF THE BOURGEOISIE
Civility and Contest
Balance and Adjustment
Senility and Madness
Loneliness and Menopause
Balance and Cartesian Possibility
The Dementia Clinic
The Way to the Indies, to the Fountain of Jouth
7. CHAPATI BODIES
Nagwa by Its Residents
Weakness as Structure
Muslims and Other Saints
Generation and Weakness Revisited
Jhandu and the Sound of Dying
The Position of Repose
A Child Is Being Lifted
8. DOG LADIES AND THE BERIYA BABA
Dogs and Old Women
Old Women and Madwomen
Madwomen and Witches
Dogs and Old Men
Old Men and Babas
Babas and the State
The Age of the Anthropologist
9. THE BODY IN TIME
My Grandmother's Letters
No One Here Cares about Alzheimer's
Lost at the Fair
A Last Few Trips up the River
NOTES
GLOSSARY
REFERENCES
INDEX
Awards
- 2003 J. I. Staley Prize, School of American Research
- 1999 American Ethnological Society Prize for best first book, American Ethnological Society